2,756
edits
Development:Discussions: Difference between revisions
no edit summary
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 12: | Line 12: | ||
* Wiki Pro and Con Article. Discussion on fundamentally important setup/decision with many pros and cons. | * Wiki Pro and Con Article. Discussion on fundamentally important setup/decision with many pros and cons. | ||
== Structured | == Decision on Structured Discussions - Do we need a Forum? == | ||
"Structured discussion are currently happen partially on Linear, Discord, and Wikipedia. | |||
Going forward we need <u>one</u> go to central place in which <u>structured</u> discussions are happening. | |||
The purpose of the next sections is to list advantages and disadvantages of each communication tool. | |||
Please add more suggestions, your arguments and final assessment. | |||
=== What are "structured discussions?" === | === What are "structured discussions?" === | ||
| Line 20: | Line 27: | ||
* Discussions with fundamental value that we want to preserve (and use to build to Wikiarticles) | * Discussions with fundamental value that we want to preserve (and use to build to Wikiarticles) | ||
== | == Option 1: Wiki Discussion Page + "Discussion Tools" == | ||
Wikipedia uses an [[Development:MediaWiki/Extensions|extension]] called "Discussion Tools" which streamlines discussions in the Wiki as it makes tagging, replying and subscribing easier. | Wikipedia uses an [[Development:MediaWiki/Extensions|extension]] called "Discussion Tools" which streamlines discussions in the Wiki as it makes tagging, replying and subscribing easier. | ||
| Line 54: | Line 49: | ||
* | * | ||
== Forums == | == Option 2: Forums == | ||
The alternative for an open work environment to discussion tools are forums. | The alternative for an open work environment to discussion tools are forums. | ||
| Line 92: | Line 87: | ||
* https://wordpress.org/plugins/wpforo/ - Discourse seems to be able to cover all relevant functions via add-on as well. | * https://wordpress.org/plugins/wpforo/ - Discourse seems to be able to cover all relevant functions via add-on as well. | ||
== Discord Threads == | == Option 3: Discord Threads == | ||
We could achieve some level clearness in discord by having more threaded discussions and linking to those threaded discussions from the Wiki. | We could achieve some level clearness in discord by having more threaded discussions and linking to those threaded discussions from the Wiki. | ||
| Line 108: | Line 103: | ||
* Discord servers have [https://www.reddit.com/r/TechSEO/comments/qxf6er/is_there_any_benefit_to_starting_a_discord_server/ no seo impact] | * Discord servers have [https://www.reddit.com/r/TechSEO/comments/qxf6er/is_there_any_benefit_to_starting_a_discord_server/ no seo impact] | ||
== Linear Workspace == | == Option 4: Linear Workspace == | ||
We could create a new Linear workspace just for discussions with the community. | We could create a new Linear workspace just for discussions with the community. | ||
| Line 120: | Line 115: | ||
* Only 250 active issues possible | * Only 250 active issues possible | ||
* No Seo | * No Seo | ||
== Option 5: More or new Ideas? == | |||
Add other ideas here. | |||
== Final Assessment == | == Final Assessment == | ||
'''<u>Moritz:</u>''' In my assessment only WikiDiscussions or Discourse makes sense for structured discussions as they full fill our openness and documentation requirements. Discord can still be used for casual chatting/discussions and Linear for Project Management. | '''<u>Moritz:</u>''' In my assessment only WikiDiscussions or Discourse makes sense for structured discussions as they full fill our openness and documentation requirements. Discord can still be used for casual chatting/discussions and Linear for Project Management. | ||